New England style pizza in Tampa Bay. Reminds me of Papa Gino’s. Good service, short waits. The Pizza Mania supreme and classic cheese are our faves. The garlic bread is Spicy Hot with garlic…definitely won’t have any vampire problems for at least a week. Love it! Try them out!
1st time and if your looking for NY style, you just got it. I’m from PA and very picky about pizza. Florida doesn’t have great pizza, this place was fantastic.. I definitely recommend. We will be back. The garlic knots were fabulous also :)
Both dine-in and take-out. Dine-in was great , everyone was very friendly. Excellent cauliflower / gluten free crust pizza (best I've ever tried). Above average salads for a pizza spot. Their plain pies are outrageously good. Truly NY style pizza.
This was a great spot for us to go as a group for lunch. We were able to get in and out during our lunch break without issues. The food is amazing and it’s always best to eat fresh from the oven. The staff is great. Will be back soon!
Best Philly cheese steak sandwich I have tried.. lots of delicious meat mixed with cheese on toasty bread for around $8.. so good I had not tried anything else in this place and sometimes I'll drive far just to get that awesome Philly cheese steak sandwich!
Pizza was delicious ! I tried them for the first time and pizza was good! I am from NY so pizza is hard to find out here that comes close to NY but me and the kids loved it! Can’t wait to try some of the other items on the menu. Definitely recommend. Staff was very nice too!
Featuring
Healthy Options
Gluten-Free Options
Easy Parking
Catering
Our Story
After moving to Florida from New Jersey in 2003, there was an opportunity present to open an authentic pizzeria. After following in their Father's foot steps, Pizza Mania was opened. Anthony's father had owned pizzerias since the 1970s, and they took that experience to Florida. As the town expanded, so did the business, and Pizza Mania very quickly became the go-to spot for pizza in the area.
Our Menu
Only Fresh Ingredients
We invest in quality ingredients to ensure our customers get the great taste we're famous for. Because we believe that you deserve the best.
Made With Love
Our secret ingredient is passion. Everyone on our team is passionate about making your time with us as great as it can be — from start to finish.
Earn rewards points for free items
Earn rewards points to get free items, discounts, updates on special events and more. Be entered in a drawing to win $500
About Us
About Us
We have been serving the area for years with high quality pizza amongst other Italian specialties. Come in and see why people can't stop talking about Pizza Mania. Now offering pickup and delivery directly from our site!